India's Premier Full-Service Law Firm — Precision. Pedigree. Global Reach.
Goldschmidt Pallonji& Associates
Get in Touch
Home/ NRI Legal Services/ FEMA & RBI Compliance
★★ NRI Legal Services — Sub-Practice

FEMA & RBI Compliance

Every financial transaction between an NRI and India is governed by FEMA 1999 and the Reserve Bank of India's Master Directions — a framework that distinguishes between permissible transactions, those requiring prior RBI approval, and those that are prohibited altogether. Getting FEMA wrong is not a technicality: contraventions can result in the transaction being void, funds being confiscated, and prosecution under FEMA's civil penalty provisions. GP provides the FEMA advisory that ensures every transaction is structured correctly before it is executed.

FEMA Compliance Advisory · Permissibility Analysis · Compounding · LRS · Overseas Investment · Reporting Obligations
FEMA 1999 · RBI Master Directions · FEMA (Non-Debt) Rules 2019 · IT Act 1961 · Enforcement Directorate
The Sub-Practice

FEMA 1999 replaced FERA 1973 with a liberalised framework that presumes current account transactions are permissible and requires prior RBI approval only for capital account transactions not covered by the Master Directions. In practice, however, the FEMA framework is anything but simple — the distinction between current and capital account transactions is fact-dependent, the Master Directions are voluminous and frequently updated, and the consequences of getting the classification wrong can be severe.

For NRIs, FEMA governs: the acquisition and transfer of immovable property in India; the maintenance of bank accounts in India (NRE, NRO, FCNR(B)); the repatriation of funds from India to the NRI's overseas account; investments in Indian securities, mutual funds, and deposits; and — following the 2022 amendments to the overseas investment regulations — the NRI's investments outside India. Each category of transaction has its own Master Direction specifying the conditions, reporting requirements, and prohibitions.

The Enforcement Directorate (ED) enforces FEMA — and its powers, including the power to attach property and impose civil penalties of up to three times the amount involved in the contravention, make FEMA compliance a serious business. Where a FEMA contravention has already occurred, the RBI's compounding mechanism provides a route to regularisation — but only if the contravention is voluntarily disclosed, fully explained, and the compounding application is properly prepared. GP's FEMA practice covers both the pre-transaction advisory (ensuring compliance before any money moves) and the post-contravention compounding (regularising past violations with the RBI).

Key FEMA Instruments
FEMA 1999 — Main Act FEMA (Non-Debt Instruments) Rules 2019 RBI Master Direction — Immovable Property RBI Master Direction — NRI Deposits Overseas Investment Rules 2022 FEMA Compounding Rules 2000
Practice at a Glance
Services
Pre-transaction compliance advisory · Permissibility analysis · Reporting obligations · Compounding applications · Overseas investment compliance · ED proceedings defence
Enforcement
Enforcement Directorate — civil penalties up to 3x contravention amount · Property attachment · Arrest in serious cases
Compounding Authority
Reserve Bank of India — Regional Offices · Compounding resolves the violation on payment of prescribed penalty
Clients
NRIs · OCIs · Returning NRIs · Indian companies with overseas operations · Authorised dealer banks on NRI compliance queries
Speak to Our NRI Team
Our Services

FEMA & RBI Compliance Services

🔍

Pre-Transaction FEMA Advisory

Permissibility analysis for proposed transactions before any money moves — confirming whether the transaction is permitted on the automatic route, requires prior RBI approval, or is prohibited. GP analyses the transaction against the applicable Master Direction, identifies any conditions or reporting requirements, and advises on the optimal structure to achieve the client's objective within the FEMA framework. The analysis covers property transactions, investments, loans, gifts, and all other categories of transaction involving NRI funds and Indian assets.

📋

FEMA Reporting Obligations

Advisory on FEMA reporting requirements — the filings that NRIs and their authorised dealer banks must make following specific categories of transaction. These include reporting of overseas direct investments (ODI forms), foreign portfolio investments, inward remittances above specified thresholds, and the annual return on foreign liabilities and assets (FLA return). Many FEMA contraventions arise from reporting failures rather than from the underlying transaction being impermissible. GP identifies the applicable reporting requirements and manages the filings.

FEMA Compounding — Regularising Past Violations

Preparation and filing of compounding applications with the RBI's Compounding Authority for past FEMA contraventions — including agricultural land purchases, NRO remittances without documentation, accounts not closed on status change, loans to non-relatives, and unreported overseas investments. GP assesses the compoundability of each contravention (not all FEMA violations are compoundable), prepares the application with full disclosure, and manages the compounding process through to the order. Compounding resolves the contravention and prevents ED action on the compounded violation.

🌎

Overseas Investment Compliance — 2022 Rules

Advisory on the Overseas Investment Rules 2022 — which significantly revised the framework for investments by Indian residents and NRIs outside India. The 2022 Rules introduced new categories of permitted investment, new reporting requirements, and new conditions on the round-tripping of overseas funds. GP advises NRIs on the permissibility of their overseas investments (which are governed by FEMA as well as the law of the overseas jurisdiction), the reporting requirements applicable to each investment category, and the management of the compliance position when the rules change mid-investment.

📊

LRS — Liberalised Remittance Scheme

Advisory on the Liberalised Remittance Scheme (LRS) — under which resident Indians (not NRIs, who use a different framework) can remit up to USD 250,000 per financial year abroad for permitted purposes. For NRIs returning to India or retaining resident family members who wish to remit funds overseas, the LRS framework applies. GP advises on the permitted purposes under LRS, the prohibited transactions (acquisition of foreign currency in India, overseas property investment above the limit, and others), and the tax collected at source (TCS) on LRS remittances above ₹7 lakh.

🚫

ED Proceedings — Defence & Representation

Representation in Enforcement Directorate proceedings — Show Cause Notices under FEMA, adjudication proceedings before the Adjudicating Authority, and appeals before the Appellate Tribunal for Foreign Exchange (ATFE). GP defends against ED allegations of FEMA contravention — challenging the jurisdiction, the characterisation of the transaction, and the quantum of the penalty — and advises on whether a compounding application during proceedings can reduce the penalty exposure. For serious FEMA matters, GP's anti-money laundering team provides integrated FEMA and PMLA defence.

Key Highlights

The most common inadvertent FEMA contraventions — and why voluntary compounding is always better than waiting for the ED.

Status Change — The Most Overlooked Obligation
When an Indian resident becomes an NRI — by taking up employment or business outside India — they are required to convert their resident bank accounts to NRO accounts within a reasonable time and to close or convert their Demat account. Many people do not do this, creating a continuing FEMA contravention for every year the accounts remain as resident accounts. Similarly, when an NRI returns to India permanently, their NRE and FCNR(B) accounts must be closed or redesignated. GP audits the client's account and investment position on status change in both directions.
Compounding — Voluntary Disclosure Rewarded
The RBI's compounding mechanism rewards voluntary disclosure — a compounding application filed before the ED has initiated proceedings typically attracts a lower penalty than one filed after the ED's Show Cause Notice. The FEMA Compounding Rules 2000 specify the penalty ranges for each category of contravention — and the RBI has discretion to reduce the penalty where the violation was inadvertent, there was no financial gain, and the applicant has a clean FEMA record. GP prepares compounding applications that present the client's position in the most favourable way consistent with complete disclosure.
NRI vs. OCI — Same FEMA Treatment (Mostly)
For most FEMA purposes, OCI cardholders are treated on par with NRIs — they can maintain NRE/NRO/FCNR(B) accounts, purchase immovable property (except agricultural land), and invest in Indian securities on the same terms as NRIs. The key differences arise in property (OCIs cannot purchase agricultural land — same as NRIs), employment (OCIs cannot hold certain government positions), and voting rights. GP advises OCI cardholders on the FEMA position with the same depth of analysis it provides to NRIs.
The Five Most Common NRI FEMA Violations

Based on GP's compounding practice, the five most frequently encountered inadvertent NRI FEMA contraventions are: (1) purchase of agricultural land; (2) NRO account remittance without Form 15CA/CB; (3) failure to convert resident accounts to NRO on becoming NRI; (4) loans to India-based non-relatives from NRE account; and (5) failure to report overseas investments. All five are compoundable — and all five are preventable with a pre-transaction FEMA advisory.

FEMA and PMLA — The Intersection

A FEMA contravention can trigger PMLA scrutiny — because FEMA violations are scheduled offences under PMLA, meaning the proceeds of a FEMA contravention are technically "proceeds of crime" under PMLA. This means the ED can pursue an NRI who committed a FEMA violation both under FEMA (civil penalty) and PMLA (attachment of property, prosecution). For serious FEMA matters, GP's anti-money laundering team provides the integrated FEMA and PMLA defence that the situation requires.

Returning NRI — FEMA Transition

When an NRI returns to India permanently, their FEMA status changes — they become a "person resident in India" and most of their NRI-specific rights and obligations change with them. NRE accounts must be closed or redesignated as resident accounts; FCNR(B) deposits must be allowed to mature or closed; overseas investments made during the NRI period can be retained but are subject to the LRS framework thereafter. GP conducts a FEMA transition audit for returning NRIs — identifying all accounts, investments, and assets that need to be re-characterised or notified, and managing the transition process.

Why GP

Why GP for FEMA & RBI Compliance

1

Advisory depth — not surface-level FEMA

Many lawyers know the headline FEMA rules — NRIs cannot buy agricultural land, NRE accounts are freely repatriable. GP's FEMA advisory goes deeper: the distinction between "close relative" for gifting purposes, the conditions on loans from NRE accounts, the interaction between FEMA and the overseas investment rules after the 2022 amendments, and the compoundability analysis for each category of contravention. The depth of the advisory matters because half-right FEMA advice is as dangerous as no FEMA advice at all.

2

FEMA and tax — integrated analysis

FEMA compliance and Indian income tax are inseparable for most NRI transactions — the Form 15CA/CB required for NRO remittances, the TDS certificate required for property sales, and the tax treaty position for income repatriated to a treaty country are all FEMA-tax intersections. GP integrates both analyses — the FEMA permissibility and the tax cost — in a single advisory, ensuring the client understands the complete cost of the transaction before they proceed.

3

Compounding expertise — the RBI process done right

A compounding application that is incomplete, inaccurate, or poorly drafted will be returned by the RBI — adding delay and potentially increasing the penalty. GP prepares compounding applications with the rigour the RBI expects: complete disclosure of every contravention, a detailed chronology, an analysis of the applicable penalty range, and a submission on mitigating factors. GP's compounding practice has a consistent record of applications accepted on the first submission and penalties at the lower end of the applicable range.

Representative Matters

The type of work we do.

India + UAEStatus Change FEMA Audit — 6 Contraventions Identified

Dubai NRI relocating back to India — GP FEMA audit identified 6 historic contraventions — all six compounded with RBI — client returned to India with clean FEMA record

A Dubai-based NRI planning to return to India permanently engaged GP for a pre-return FEMA audit. The audit identified six historic contraventions across 14 years as an NRI: resident savings account not converted to NRO on becoming NRI (2009); NRO remittances to Dubai account in 2013, 2015, and 2017 without Form 15CA/CB documentation; a loan of ₹15 lakh from the NRE account to a non-close-relative (2016); and an unreported overseas investment in a Singapore private company (2018). GP prepared six compounding applications, filed sequentially with the RBI's Mumbai regional office, with complete disclosure of each contravention and a detailed submission on the inadvertent nature and clean record otherwise. All six were compounded. The client returned to India with a fully regularised FEMA position.

India + SingaporeOverseas Investment Compliance — 2022 Rules

Singapore NRI — restructuring overseas investment portfolio — 2022 Overseas Investment Rules analysis — reporting obligations identified — ODI filings completed — investment structure regularised

Advised a Singapore-based NRI on the FEMA compliance position of his overseas investment portfolio following the Overseas Investment Rules 2022 — which introduced significant changes to the framework for Indian persons' overseas investments. The client held interests in three Singapore companies and a Cayman Islands fund — all made during his NRI period but potentially subject to new reporting requirements under the 2022 rules. GP analysed each investment against the new framework, identified the applicable ODI reporting forms, prepared and filed the required reports with the RBI (facilitated through the client's authorised dealer bank), and advised on the steps needed to bring the Cayman fund investment within the new permitted categories — including the restructuring that was required to avoid the new round-tripping restrictions.

DelhiED Show Cause Notice — FEMA Defence

Delhi exporter — ED Show Cause Notice alleging FEMA contravention on export proceeds — response filed — violation found technical and non-wilful — penalty reduced to ₹50,000 against demand of ₹42 lakh

Defended a Delhi-based exporter who received a Show Cause Notice from the Enforcement Directorate alleging FEMA contravention arising from export proceeds not being credited to the exporter's account within the prescribed period. The ED alleged a contravention of ₹14 lakh in unrealised export proceeds, demanding a civil penalty of ₹42 lakh (three times the amount). GP filed a detailed response demonstrating that the delay was caused entirely by the foreign buyer's bank hold — supported by SWIFT messages and correspondence — and that the exporter had followed up consistently and in good faith. The Adjudicating Authority accepted GP's response and imposed a token penalty of ₹50,000 in lieu of the ₹42 lakh demand — finding the contravention technical and non-wilful.

Practice Leadership

GP's FEMA practice combines pre-transaction advisory depth with a proven compounding practice and, for serious matters, integrated FEMA and PMLA defence — covering the complete spectrum of NRI FEMA compliance needs.

Every NRI engagement at GP begins with a FEMA compliance check — confirming the permissibility of the proposed transaction before any money moves. For returning NRIs, GP conducts a pre-return FEMA audit to identify and regularise any historic contraventions before the NRI is back in India and subject to resident Indian obligations. For active FEMA and ED matters, GP's anti-money laundering team provides integrated defence.

GP updates its FEMA advisory practice continuously as the RBI issues new Master Directions and circulars — ensuring the advice clients receive reflects the current position, not a position that changed with the last RBI circular.

GP
FEMA & RBI Compliance
Advisory · Compounding · ED Defence · Audit · OI Rules
Pre-Transaction Advisory Compounding Applications Reporting Obligations ED SCN Defence 2022 OI Rules
NRI Corridors: UAE · UK · Australia · Singapore · USA · Canada
✉ Write to Our NRI Team All NRI Legal Services
Latest Insights
FEMA Compounding Guide

FEMA Compounding — How to Regularise Past NRI Violations Before the Enforcement Directorate Finds Them

What compounding is, the five most commonly compounded NRI violations, the application process, and why voluntary disclosure consistently produces lower penalties.

Read Guide →
Returning NRI

Returning to India? The FEMA Transition Checklist — Every Account, Investment and Asset You Need to Regularise Before Your Status Changes

NRE to resident account conversion, FCNR(B) maturity, overseas investment retention rights, and the LRS framework for your post-return remittances.

Read Guide →
FEMA & RBI Compliance

Speak to Our NRI Team

Whether you need a pre-transaction FEMA check, have discovered a past violation, are returning to India, or have received an ED notice — speak to GP today.

Pre-transaction FEMA advisory — before any money moves
Compounding applications · Pre-return FEMA audit
ED Show Cause Notice defence · ATFE appeals
Send Us a Message

Strictly confidential. FEMA matters handled with complete discretion across all time zones.